Confidential Advice Line: 0800 063 9221

Landmark Decision on Lehman Changes Creditor Priorities in UK Insolvencies


A landmark decision has been handed down in the UK courts, which has changed the order of priorities for creditors in UK insolvencies and which threatens to undermine the whole basis on which banks lend to UK corporates, especially those in distress.

The decision clarifies the status of a Financial Support Direction ("FSD") issued by the UK Pensions Regulator against insolvent companies. An FSD is an order requiring a company to put in place financial support measures to underpin deficits in UK pension schemes. Typically, an FSD orders a company to make additional contributions into the pension scheme. The effect of the decision, granted in favour of the Trustees of the Lehman Pension Scheme in the UK and against the Lehman Administrators in the UK is that the liabilities created by an FSD which is issued after the commencement of the insolvency must be paid out by the Administrators as an expense of the Administration, rather than as an unsecured claim. This is good news for those who are members of UK pensions schemes, but not for anyone else concerned with business rescue.

This puts the FSD claim ahead of all creditors and also ahead of the Administrators' own fees and expenses. This is of obvious concern to insolvency practitioners, since in many cases, the FSD liabilities will be of such a magnitude that it would absorb the whole realisations in a case, leaving nothing to pay their fees or costs. Fortunately, Mr Justice Briggs softened the blow by concluding that the Court did have jurisdiction to order that an insolvency practitioner's fees should be paid ahead of the FSD liabilities, but deep uncertainty remains. It is clear that the law needs clarifying in this respect.

The position for unsecured creditors and any bank holding a floating charge over the company's assets is probably the most worrying outcome of this judgement. Banks and other lenders may be unwilling to support companies, especially those facing financial difficulties, if they feel that there is a risk of having their security leap-frogged by massive claims from the Pensions Regulator over which they have no control. In the present shaky recovery in the UK, this is the last thing that the business community needs.

The decision is going to appeal and the outcome will be eagerly but nervously awaited by all interested parties and the whole UK banking sector and the insolvency profession.

We will be delighted to provide answers to any questions you may have, or to refer you for specialist advice if you or your clients have any immediate issues with this potentially unpleasant and unexpected decision.


About the author

Julie Palmer

Regional Managing Partner

Meet our Team of Experts

Julie is a law graduate who qualified with Price Waterhouse in 1994. Julie joined Smith & Williamson in 1997 and became a partner in 2001. With Mike Stevenson, Julie set up Middleton Partners offices in Salisbury and Southampton, both of which are now part of Begbies Traynor.

Julie is a member of the Insolvency Practitioners Association and the None Administrative Receivers Association and is a Fellow of The Association of Business Recovery Professionals. Julie deals with all aspects of Corporate Recovery and turnaround work and takes all form of personal insolvency appointments.

44 Regional UK Offices

Find your local Begbies Traynor office and speak to an adviser today.

Find your Local Office
0800 063 9221

Call our Confidential Advice Line. Calls to this number are free of charge.

Call us now...
Request a Meeting

We invite you to come and discuss your enquiry with us at your convenience.

Request a meeting...
0800 464 0871

Call our Confidential Advice Line. Calls to this number are free of charge.

Call us now...
Request a Meeting

We invite you to come and discuss your enquiry with us at your convenience.

Request a meeting...
0161 837 1700

Call our Confidential Advice Line. Calls to this number are free of charge.

Call us now...
Request a Meeting

We invite you to come and discuss your enquiry with us at your convenience.

Request a meeting...
Businesses Remain Resilient in the face of Brexit
Financial distress falls 6% following referendum
ONS data: 'Brexit has had no major effect on the UK economy thus far'
Read More →
 
Open Banking to Reshape the Alternative Finance Sector
CMA mandates the adoption of Open Banking by early 2018
Will see alternative lenders competing on a level playing field with dominant banks
Read more →
 
Join thousands of professionals by signing up for our updates
Analysis and Opinion from our Partners
Top Industry News
Register Now →
 

Advice you can trust

We are accredited by the following industry leading organisations

Insolvency Practitioners Association Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales R3: Association of Business Recovery Professionals ICAEW Business Advice Service Turnaround Management Association ACCA (the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants) ICAS | The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland

Contact the Begbies Traynor team

or Find your Nearest Office
Processing...