Member of BTG Global Advisory

What is the Difference Between Fraudulent and Wrongful Trading?

If you fear that your company has reached an insolvent position, you must be very careful to cease trading immediately. Insolvency is when you are unable to pay bills as they fall due, or when the total of company liabilities exceeds the total value of assets held.

Trading insolvently is likely to lead to accusations of wrongful trading, or the more serious charge of fraudulent trading, if you are thought to have deliberately attempted to deny creditors what they are owed.

Both wrongful trading and fraudulent trading are offences under the Insolvency Act 1986 and the Companies Act 2006. Wrongful trading is a civil offence, while fraudulent trading is a criminal offence.

It is incumbent on a director to be aware of their company’s financial position at all times, and putting forward a defence that you were unaware of the insolvent situation will carry little weight. Failing to realise that a company is in financial difficulties may be regarded as negligent, irresponsible, or proof of ‘unfit conduct’ as directors, simply adding to the seriousness of the situation.

Begbies Traynor offers a same-day consultation free of charge if you are unsure of your company’s financial position.

Fraudulent trading

If creditors have taken legal action against your company, and you are facing voluntary or compulsory liquidation, your conduct as a director will come under scrutiny during the liquidation process. This is a very serious allegation that can lead to a prison sentence, director disqualification and/or financial penalties.

The Insolvency Practitioner dealing with the liquidation is obliged to send a report to the Secretary of State on the conduct of directors leading up to the company’s insolvency. If fraudulent trading is suspected, as opposed to wrongful trading, it means that directors have been considered to act to deliberately avoid payment of company liabilities.

Continuing in business, whether that means accepting lines of credit from suppliers, or taking payment on credit from customers knowing that the orders will be unfulfilled, and attempting to maximise the amount of money coming in prior to liquidation, is a serious offence.

Selling company assets at a price less than market value during the time leading up to liquidation could also be viewed with suspicion by the investigating Insolvency Practitioner or team.

The intention to defraud creditors in this way has to be proven, however, and the Insolvency Service will carry out a thorough investigation in an attempt to reach the truth.

Wrongful trading

A judgment of wrongful trading carries with it potential disqualification as a director for up to 15 years, plus other financial fines and penalties. Being held personally liable for company debts is also a possibility. Although not considered a criminal offence, wrongful trading is a civil offence which is taken very seriously by the courts.

Directors have an obligation to inform company shareholders when an insolvent position has been reached, and to seek the guidance of a licensed Insolvency Practitioner.

Although directors may have carried on trading with good intentions in order to ultimately guide the company out of trouble, they have a duty to put creditors’ interests first when insolvency strikes and to limit creditors’ exposure to additional debt.

If it is found that you have shown preference to one or two creditors over others, you may face questions as to your motives. The interests of creditors as a whole should be at the forefront of director actions, rather than individual creditors.

Begbies Traynor is the largest UK business recovery practice with with an extensive UK office network.Contact a member of our expert team to discuss your business situation.

Contact our team

Latest News
York taxi company placed into administration
York taxi company placed into administration
On 25th November 2016, Rob Sadler and Dave Broadbent of Begbies Traynor in York were appointed as joint administrators of Six Five Nine Cars Ltd. The business, which has traded in York for over 15 yea…
40 jobs saved as gaming retailer sold out of administration
40 jobs saved as gaming retailer sold out of administration
Administrators of a South West-based gaming retailer have succeeded in saving 40 jobs at the company after securing the sale of the business, including 12 out of 15 of its High Street stores. Business…
Nearly 100 jobs saved as bars and restaurants are sold out of administration
Nearly 100 jobs saved as bars and restaurants are sold out of administration
Almost 100 jobs have been saved by the successful sale out of administration of a number of Midlands bars and restaurants. Town and Country Inns plc appointed business recovery and rescue specialists …
Begbies Traynor opens new office in Taunton
Begbies Traynor opens new office in Taunton
The UK's leading independent business recovery practice, Begbies Traynor, has opened an office in Taunton.  The move will enable the firm to build on work it has already done in the town and with the…
Brexit uncertainty puts the brake on London businesses
Brexit uncertainty puts the brake on London businesses
New research reveals that British businesses from Land's End to John o' Groats have shown surprising resilience since the EU Referendum result was announced, with levels of financial distress falling…
UK businesses remain resilient in the face of Brexit
UK businesses remain resilient in the face of Brexit
UK businesses across nearly every sector of the economy were showing positive signs of stability following the EU Referendum, new research from Begbies Traynor, the UK’s leading independent insolven…

Advice You Can Trust

Insolvency Practitioners Association Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales R3: Association of Business Recovery Professionals ICAEW Business Advice Service Turnaround Management Association ACCA (the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants) ICAS | The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland