Published: 13th October 2010
Over 123,000 UK companies are struggling under the weight of nearly £58 billion worth of liabilities, according to the latest quarterly Red Flag Alert, issued today by Begbies Traynor, the UK’s leading business recovery specialist.
The report, which monitors the early warning signs of company distress, has found that 123,361 companies experienced ‘significant’ or ‘critical’ financial distress in Q3 2010, with those experiencing ‘critical’ financial problems owing over £57.5 billion to creditors, suppliers and service providers.
Public sector already suffering
This news comes against a challenging backdrop. Earlier this month, house prices registered their biggest ever monthly fall, and next week the government is preparing to announce the results of the Comprehensive Spending Review, in which it is expected to reveal a raft of spending cuts which will hit those businesses most dependent on public spending hard.
According to Red Flag Alert, 50,299 companies are already experiencing financial distress in these sectors which cover construction, IT, recruitment, advertising and business services. Whilst this represents a slight improvement on the previous quarter, (down 4% compared to 51,711 in Q2 2010), overall the figures show a marked slowdown in the rate of recovery when compared to the 20% improvement in Q2 2010 from 64,805 in Q1 2010. This sharp reversal of fortunes was particularly pronounced in the advertising sector, down 29% between Q1 and Q2 2010, but now revealing a 27% increase in businesses experiencing financial distress in the sector from 705 in Q2 to 892 in Q3 2010.
Ric Traynor, Executive Chairman of Begbies Traynor Group, said: “It will not be until the Government’s Comprehensive Spending Review in a week’s time that we will know for certain the allocation of all of the anticipated £83 billion of spending cuts. However, our Red Flag Alert statistics show that the sectors most likely to be most impacted are already starting to shows definite signs of financial distress. With confidence in the construction sector falling to an eighteen month low2, recruitment activity at its slowest for almost a year3 and a strong increase in distress in the advertising sector, there is a growing risk that even if the wider UK avoids a double dip recession, public-sector dependent industries face higher levels of financial distress.”
The slowdown in the rate of recovery has been found across the board in the latest Red Flag Alert statistics. Overall, although the number of companies experiencing distress has fallen by 10% compared to 137,268 in Q3 2009, the rate of recovery is the slowest for five quarters and compares to a 31% decline in distress in Q2 2010 versus Q2 2009.
In addition, this latest quarter has also been marked by a significant increase in the number of HMRC wind-up petitions - up 39% between August and September, showing that the government may understandably be getting tougher on chasing taxes to increase revenues from both corporates and individuals.
Traynor added: “The decline in the numbers of businesses in distress reflects a combination of lenient creditor attitudes and the effects of temporary government support initiatives, including quantitative easing, the time to pay scheme and low interest rates.
“However, the marked slowdown in the rate of recovery points to the renewed challenges facing UK corporates, as reflected by a recent significant weakening in corporate confidence1, and there is some early evidence that creditors such as HMRC are adopting a harder line in collecting debts.
“Our Red Flag Alert statistics do not fully account for the substantial number of informal arrangements being made between companies and their creditors behind the scenes. We urge businesses to formalise those arrangements, which are not currently legally binding, while creditors remain more sympathetic or risk harsher terms or adverse actions in the future.”
Further distress expected in the consumer facing industries
The consumer facing sectors of retail, leisure and travel have also seen a slowdown in their rate of recovery. 15,500 companies are experiencing financial distress, representing a 7% improvement from 16,650 in Q2 2010 compared to an 11% improvement in Q2 2010 from 15,436 in Q1 2010.
Traynor added: “Retail, leisure and travel are already seeing a slowing rate of recovery ahead of greater pressure on consumers' disposable incomes from increased VAT rates and public spending cuts. With recent evidence of house price reductions4, falls in consumer credit5 and lower savings ratios6, we expect a combination of deteriorating consumer confidence and financial resources to result in growing numbers of business failures in those sectors most exposed to discretionary spending.
“Whilst the retail sector may benefit from a short term boost as consumers purchase bigger ticket items ahead of the VAT rise in January, we expect to see a significant rise in failures in the sector from the first quarter of 2011.”
Unwinding of government support measures starting to have an impact
In addition, Red Flag Alert also shows that there was an 11% increase in companies experiencing financial problems in the automotive sector from 3,007 in Q2 2010 to 3,352 in Q3 2010.
Traynor added: “The automotive sector represents the first sector to feel the impact of the unwinding of temporary government support measures, as shown in an 11% increase in financial distress during the period following the withdrawal of the UK car scrappage scheme in March this year.”
“We believe that there will be a prolonged period of growth in business distress, as SMEs feel the full impact of the gradual unwinding of government support measures combined with public sector spending cuts and deteriorating business and consumer confidence.
“The £57.5 billion of liabilities still at risk of default by businesses in distress remains a very real and potentially far-reaching threat to creditors and to a smooth economic recovery.
“As the government has acknowledged, its key challenge is to strike the fine balance between maintaining confidence in its ability to reduce the UK’s deficit, whilst ensuring that cuts to public sector spending and the withdrawal of temporary support measures are sufficiently staggered to maintain the recovery.”
Ric qualified with Arthur Andersen in 1984 and founded Begbies Traynor in 1989. Ric specialises in practice management and has considerable experience in financial turnaround and dispute resolution within professional practices.