Published: 27th January 2020
Updated: 8th February 2021
When a limited company is unable to meet its liabilities as they fall due, it may be insolvent. There are, however, a range of options that could save the company from closure. Which option is taken depends on whether the underlying business can be made profitable again by restructuring or selling off some of the assets.
Once a company is known to be insolvent, professional insolvency advice should be sought as a matter of urgency. When a company reaches this stage, directors must act in the best interests of their creditors and seek to limit further losses as much as possible. Trading while knowingly insolvent could jeopardise this and could see directors being held personally liable for company debts, and leave themselves open to accusations of fraudulent trading. Begbies Traynor is the largest UK business recovery practice – our people are experts in corporate recovery, and can offer guidance in this respect.
As a director of an insolvent company you must be able to demonstrate responsibility as far as your creditors are concerned and act with their best interests in mind.
In summary, these are the initial actions that should be taken if your company is struggling to pay multiple debts
This involves negotiating revised payment terms with creditors. Your appointed Insolvency Practitioner (IP) will analyse the company’s finances and put together a plan for repayment, which is then presented to creditors.
If the proposal is agreed, there are several benefits for both company and creditors. As far as your company is concerned, you should see an immediate increase in cash flow thanks to the consolidation of multiple debt repayments into a single monthly payment.
Trade will carry on under the same directorship, offering continuity of business. Creditors generally receive a higher return by agreeing a CVA, when compared with company liquidation. They continue to trade with a company they know, but without the stresses of unpaid debts.
If one of the debts in question concerns Corporation Tax, VAT or PAYE, you will need to contact HMRC immediately.
HMRC debts can be particularly problematic for directors, as the system is set up to spot late payers very quickly. This often results in HMRC taking action to liquidate a company if it believes that company may be approaching insolvency.
The good news is that HMRC offers an instalment plan called a Time to Pay arrangement. This gives companies experiencing a temporary debt problem an extended period of time to pay their tax liabilities – typically between 3 and 12 months.
It is fair to say that negotiating with HMRC is a daunting prospect, and this is why some directors choose to appoint a licensed insolvency practitioner to put together and present their case to HMRC.
HMRC needs to trust your judgement regarding the company’s ability to pay future instalments and adhere to the terms of the agreement, and the case is strengthened by using professional insolvency experts to guide you.
As we have said previously, speed is of the essence when your ability to pay HMRC is in doubt. You may be able to limit or avoid penalties for late payment and reduce the chances of your company’s financial position deteriorating further if you take action right away.
Pre-pack administration may be a possibility if there is no other viable option for recovery in the company's original form. In this instance, the business is sold as a going concern, often to one or more existing directors, who go on to form a new company, or ‘newco’.
The most appropriate buyer for the underlying business may be its existing directors but could equally be that a trade buyer or another third party is more suitable.
One of the requirements of pre-pack administration is that the assets are purchased using the buyer’s personal funds at a fair market price, which may limit the directors’ ability to proceed.
The advantage of using pre-pack administration for a company in debt is the speed of sale. Negotiations for the sale of assets take place before administrators are officially appointed, with the actual sale taking place shortly after. Not only does this help to preserve the value of business assets, there is unlikely to be adverse publicity about the administration process when it is carried out so quickly.
It is incumbent on the IP to prove that no better options exist as far as creditors are concerned, which helps to alleviate some of the ethical issues surrounding pre-pack administration and ensures that the best deal is obtained for creditors.
Begbies Traynor is the largest UK business recovery practice. We offer a free initial consultation, and operate from offices across the country.